Trump tells aides Vance should have defended Iran war decision
The New York Times reported the private complaints as Trump praises Rubio behind closed doors.

President Donald Trump has spent the past two weeks complaining to aides and allies that Vice President JD Vance, in blaming the Iran war for the Republican midterm rout, should have said the president made the right call in starting it, The New York Times reported Wednesday.
The report, by Times White House correspondent Tyler Pager, cited people with knowledge of the president's comments who spoke on condition of anonymity. Those people said Trump has kept praising Secretary of State Marco Rubio in private and has suggested he could be a strong presidential candidate. Trump's allies have noted that Rubio called the attack on Iran essential to national security.
In public, Trump's assessment of the post has been mild. He told reporters he thought it was "largely true," and his comments about the vice president since the election have been largely supportive. The private complaints, by the Times's account, built over the same two weeks.
What Vance wrote
Vance published the assessment on X the day after the Nov. 3 midterms, an election in which Republicans lost the Senate. He blamed the war outright and challenged anyone who disagreed to argue that the loss of the chamber for six years had been worth paying.
Kobi Barda, a US affairs expert at the Holon Institute of Technology's Multidisciplinary School, told Israel's 103FM radio that Vance listed four reasons for the Republican collapse, among them the campaign in Iran, which Vance described as encouraged by Israel, and a call to reconsider the relationship with Israel. Minutes later, Barda said, Donald Trump Jr. reposted the message with the comment "100%."
Trump replaced White House chief of staff Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller on Nov. 6, three days after the election. Barda, who called the rift a family feud, said Wiles and Donald Trump Jr. were the two figures who had pushed for Vance's selection as vice president. He said her removal was understood as a way to cut Vance out of decision-making.
Kansas had not elected a Democratic senator in 94 years before this month, a defeat Barda called one of biblical proportions.
Senator Ted Cruz, whom Barda described as the war's most enthusiastic supporter and a personal friend of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, said in a podcast the day after the vote that the campaign should have been short and conclusive, Al Jazeera reported.
The post, in his words
Vance framed the argument as a test of honesty rather than a break with the president. He did not criticize Trump's stated reasons for striking Iran, and he closed by writing that everyone knew why the party lost and that "any honest conversation about where we go from here must start there."
The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night. If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so.
The Times reported that Trump appeared unfazed at first. The complaint he has made behind closed doors since is narrower: not that Vance misread the election, but that he left out any defense of the decision to attack Iran, which the president regards as the right call.
The White House did not respond to a request for comment on Wednesday. When the Times reported friction between the two men in May, communications director Steven Cheung said media narratives built on unknown and unnamed sources did not reflect the truth.
Vice President Vance has done a remarkable job of helping implement the president's America First agenda.
Free. One click to unsubscribe.
Trump's preference for a successor has shifted toward Rubio since the midterms, The Daily Beast reported. Rubio has defended the war in public on many occasions, and speaking to reporters on Nov. 8 he said that confronting difficult challenges for the country's security is not always popular but is necessary.
Rubio on the Asia trip
Rubio traveled with Trump for the president's round of talks in Asia, which are set to include a trilateral meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. Vance stayed in the United States. The Daily Beast described the secretary of state as positioning himself as Trump's right-hand man.
At the ASEAN summit in Manila on Nov. 17, Trump turned the question of his secretary of state over to reporters. "How hot is Marco, right?" he said, adding that Rubio had been fantastic. The Times has reported that at a Rose Garden Club dinner in May, Trump asked guests which of the two they preferred as commander in chief, and Vance drew the louder response.
Asked during a 60 Minutes interview with the CBS correspondent Ross Douthat who, besides Vance, could carry the Republican nomination in 2028, Trump named Rubio and no one else, saying he was doing a fantastic job. He said vaguely that there were many others. Both men have dismissed speculation about running.
Vance denies a rift
Vance denied any split with the president in a Fox News interview with Laura Ingraham broadcast Nov. 16. There is "no daylight," he said, adding that the president makes decisions and is owed a cabinet that helps implement them. He said he was happy to serve as a heat shield for a president his critics lacked the courage to attack directly.
He acknowledged a political price in higher gas and energy prices and said American operations had destroyed Iran's nuclear program and its conventional military. Trump is weighing whether to declare the campaign finished or to increase military and diplomatic pressure on Tehran, Vance said. He said Trump would not let the conflict become a forever war, and gave no timetable for ending it.
The Iran file, reassigned
Trump wrote on Truth Social on Nov. 12 that he had asked Vance to turn his attention to alleged corruption in Democratic-led states, and he declared that the United States no longer needed a deal with Iran, the Jerusalem Post reported.
The Wall Street Journal reported that Trump has privately questioned whether the June memorandum of understanding that Vance helped negotiate with Iran was a costly mistake that gave Tehran time to regroup.
Trump told the conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt on Nov. 12 that it would "absolutely" be a defeat if Iran's leaders were still in power when he left office. He said he saw no immediate need for military force because the United States controlled the Strait of Hormuz, though he did not rule it out.
Barda said he expected Trump to tighten economic pressure on Tehran rather than resume strikes, giving the approach two years' grace, and that the president's window for renewed military action was narrowing, with the 60-day limit on a declared campaign having run out in September.
Open questions on 2028
CNN reported on Nov. 13 that Vance has given serious consideration to sitting out the 2028 race, citing people close to him, and that Trump has not committed to endorsing his vice president and has told aides he wants to stay out of the primary for a while. Vance has set no timeline. Neither the president nor the White House has said whether he will take back the Iran portfolio.
More from Threadline News
PoliticsSUV kills three people outside North Hollywood Metro station11 Nov 2026
PoliticsSecret Service arrests driver and fence jumper near White House10 Nov 2026
PoliticsDriver, 76, charged with felony death by vehicle in Wake County crash8 Nov 2026
PoliticsFive federal agencies warn of attacks on freezer controls6 Nov 2026
PoliticsLaKesha Womack unseats Tim Moore with felony charge pending6 Nov 2026
PoliticsMegyn Kelly urges Republicans to rebuild without Trump on the ballot5 Nov 2026Free. One click to unsubscribe, in every email. We do not sell or share addresses: privacy.
The Numbers
AllOfficial series, each dated to the observation it comes from.
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis